In brief: In Episode 3 of The Psychologist, Dr. Bart Rossi argues that Americans’ frustration with taxes is about more than the amount they pay: the system feels unfair, out of their control and rigged toward people with the best accountants. His proposal is to replace the federal income tax and the IRS as we know it with a consumption tax, sometimes called a value-added tax, so that people pay according to what they buy. He acknowledges the plan would hit lower-income households harder and says that problem can be fixed. Watch the episode below, followed by the context behind his arguments.
Why does Dr. Rossi say the tax system feels broken?
His starting point is psychological: people dislike systems they cannot understand or control. Earning more and landing in a higher bracket, he says, feels like a penalty for working harder, while the very wealthy, those earning tens or hundreds of millions, often pay less than their incomes suggest. He cites Warren Buffett, who famously wrote in a 2011 New York Times op-ed that he paid a lower tax rate than the people who worked in his office. Add payroll taxes, sales taxes and property taxes on top, and Dr. Rossi argues that Americans have lost any sense that the system makes sense.
What does he propose instead?
A national consumption tax. Under his plan, income would not be taxed by the federal government; spending would. Someone buying a Chevrolet pays tax on a Chevrolet; someone buying a $500,000 Bentley, a yacht or a new casino pays far more. The wealthy, he reasons, cannot avoid a tax that is collected at the register, and cash earned “under the table” gets taxed when it is spent. Saving would not be taxed, which he notes is good for the economy too.
The idea is not new. The United States is the only one of the 38 member countries of the OECD without a national value-added tax, and proposals such as the “FairTax,” which would replace the income tax with a national sales tax, have been introduced in Congress for years without passing.
What about lower-income households?
Dr. Rossi is upfront about the main objection: a consumption tax is regressive, meaning lower-income people, who spend most of what they earn, would pay a bigger share of their income than they do now. His answer is that the country is wealthy enough to offset it, through a monthly payment or an exemption card for people below a certain income until they earn more. Several consumption-tax plans include a similar rebate. “I’m a psychologist, not an economist,” he says, but he argues the fairness principle is the point.
Why hasn’t either party done it?
In his reading, both parties are protecting the status quo. Democrats, he says, keep promising to “tax the wealthy,” which he thinks alarms people who expect to earn more themselves. Republicans, who have long campaigned on lower taxes and less government, have little reason to embrace a tax that would make high earners pay on everything they buy. The result, he argues, is that Americans of every age are disgusted with the system and neither party is offering a fix.
Sunshine and showers
This week both parties went to the showers. Dr. Rossi suggested each has an opening: Democrats, if they succeeded in the midterms, would need an answer to “what will you actually do?”, and a consumption tax could be it; Republicans could reclaim their identity as the party of less taxation by backing the idea themselves.
Related commentary
- The Psychologist, Episode 2: Why America’s Health Care Chaos Is a Mental Health Problem
- The Psychologist, Episode 1: Trump’s “Frame of Reference” and the Winning Personality Test
- The Psychologist, Episode 5: Affordability



