In brief: In Episode 4 of The Psychologist, Dr. Bart Rossi asks the question he says the voter-fraud debate never answers: where are the names? Years after 2020, he argues, the claims of widespread fraud have produced no evidence of an organized scheme, and the psychology of the alleged crime does not add up. His explanation for why the claim persists is what he calls “the anger factor.” Watch the episode below, followed by the facts behind his arguments.
What is Dr. Rossi asking for?
Names. If fraud is as widespread as claimed, he says, show him ten or twenty people in California, Texas, Florida or New York who committed it. His point is not that no one has ever cast an illegal ballot, but that the scale of the claim and the scale of the evidence are wildly out of proportion.
The record supports that point. An Associated Press review of every potential case of voter fraud in the six battleground states Mr. Trump disputed in 2020 found fewer than 475, a number that could not have changed the outcome. Prosecutions do happen, but they are few and almost always involve one person acting alone; in Wisconsin, five people statewide were charged out of nearly 3.3 million presidential ballots.
Why does he say the crime doesn’t make psychological sense?
Because of the risk-reward math. A person voting illegally, he argues, risks federal and state charges and prison, and in the case of a non-citizen, deportation, all to add a single vote that will almost certainly not decide anything. There is no payoff that justifies the risk. That is consistent with what the AP found: virtually every case was an individual acting alone, not a coordinated effort.
What is “the anger factor”?
If the fraud is not there, why does the claim keep coming back? Dr. Rossi’s answer is that it is useful. Telling supporters that elections are being stolen by immigrants or “others,” he argues, channels resentment into a sense of grievance and a reason to restrict who can vote. In his view, that taps into bias against immigrants and people of color, and it builds political support on something that does not exist.
What does this have to do with the SAVE America Act?
He connects the fraud narrative to the SAVE America Act, which narrowly passed the House in February 2026 and would require documentary proof of citizenship, such as a passport or birth certificate, to register to vote. Supporters say it protects election security. Dr. Rossi, like many critics, argues it would keep eligible citizens from voting, pointing to married women whose current names do not match their birth certificates. (A later Senate version added exceptions for people who have changed their names.) The bill has stalled in the Senate, where it faces a filibuster. “The SAVE America Act is an act that doesn’t save voting,” he says. “It prevents voting.”
Sunshine and showers
The showers went to President Trump, who has continued to claim widespread fraud, including that he would have won California without it, without producing the people responsible. The sunshine went to Georgia Senator Jon Ossoff, who has made the question “Who won the 2020 election?” a test for Trump nominees. At a July 2026 confirmation hearing, he pressed Jay Clayton, the nominee for Director of National Intelligence, repeatedly; Clayton refused to answer. “We have a lot of problems in this country,” Dr. Rossi concludes, “but voter fraud is not one of them.”
Related commentary
- The Psychologist, Episode 1: Trump’s “Frame of Reference” and the Winning Personality Test
- The Voters Spoke Clearly. Why Is the GOP Answering With Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan?
- What Is Political Psychology? How the Mind Shapes Politics
Sources
- AP review finds far too little vote fraud to tip 2020 election to Trump – PBS NewsHour / Associated Press
- A Republican plan to overhaul voting is back. Here’s what’s new in the bill – NPR
- 9 Things to Know About the Proposed SAVE America Act – National Conference of State Legislatures
- Sen. Ossoff Presses Director of National Intelligence Nominee on 2020 Election Results – Office of Sen. Jon Ossoff
- The Psychologist Podcast, Episode 4: Voter Fraud – YouTube



