In brief: In Episode 5 of The Psychologist, Dr. Bart Rossi argues that “affordability” has become shorthand for something bigger than gas and grocery prices: a deep discontent with the American system itself, from health care and taxes to war and a Congress that rejects ideas by label. His prescription is effective government rather than less government, real compromise between the parties, and a new generation of leaders who feel the cost of living themselves. Watch the episode below, followed by the context behind his arguments.
Why does Dr. Rossi say affordability is about more than prices?
Prices matter, he says, and gas and oil prices rose sharply with the war in Iran. But the frustration runs deeper. Americans are unhappy with health care, with taxes, with a war many did not want, and with politicians on both sides who do not seem to solve anything. “We’re just not happy people,” he says; maybe sports is the only thing left that people can relate to without feeling overwhelmed. Affordability, in his reading, is the word that discontent has attached itself to.
What does he mean by “effective government”?
For decades, he notes, voters have heard that the goal is less government. As a psychologist, he finds that framing unhelpful. A military, a health care system and a tax system all require a government that works. “We always say be the best you can be,” he says. “We should have the government be the best it can be.” He points to his earlier episodes as examples: a national health care model built on traditional Medicare (Episode 2) and a tax system people can understand (Episode 3).
Why does mental health spending come up?
As an example of government cutting where it costs more later. The nation’s main mental health agency, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, shrank by more than half during 2025 as the administration moved to fold it into a new “Administration for a Healthy America,” even as officials blamed mental illness for many of the country’s problems. Dr. Rossi, who acknowledges his bias as a psychologist, argues that untreated mental illness ends up in emergency rooms, hospitals and prisons, where taxpayers pay far more.
Why does the timing matter?
The holiday season. Gifts, travel and family gatherings all cost more, Dr. Rossi notes, so the affordability debate is likely to sharpen through December rather than fade. He also takes issue with the president’s description of the issue: Mr. Trump has called affordability a “hoax” invented by Democrats.
Who should lead?
Younger people, he argues, in both parties: candidates who have trouble with their own grocery bills and commutes, and who would rather fix the tax brackets they are about to climb into than defend them.
Sunshine and showers
The sunshine went to David Hogg, the Parkland shooting survivor who runs Leaders We Deserve, a group that backs candidates under 35 for Congress and under 30 for state legislatures. Dr. Rossi credits him for pushing a new generation into the House and Senate. The showers went to President Trump, for what Dr. Rossi calls the chaos and economic instability of the past year, a war he believes was unnecessary, and dismissing affordability as a hoax.
Related commentary
- The Psychologist, Episode 2: Why America’s Health Care Chaos Is a Mental Health Problem
- The Psychologist, Episode 3: Why Americans Hate the Tax System, and the Case for a Consumption Tax
- The Voters Spoke Clearly. Why Is the GOP Answering With Stephen Miller and Jim Jordan?



